Guide Using the Hook Comparison Tool
The Hook Comparison Tool lets you place up to four hooks side by side and study how they differ — in their documented specifications, their measured dimensions, and their actual silhouettes. It also ranks the rest of the catalog by how closely each hook could substitute for one you have chosen. This guide walks through every feature in turn. If you prefer to learn as you go, the same material is available inside the tool itself: click ? Help at the top right for a condensed, tabbed version.
The tool serves three kinds of visitor, and the same features answer each of their questions: the working fly tyer asking “what current hook can I tie this pattern on instead?”, the collector asking “is this loose hook the model I think it is?”, and the researcher asking “how does this maker’s geometry relate to that one’s?”
1 Getting Started: Selecting Hooks
Everything begins with the selector at the top of the tool. Use the search box to type part of a model name or number, and use the dropdown filters — bend family, shank length, wire gauge, eye type, manufacturer, era, application and more — to narrow the catalog down to the hooks you care about. The filters combine, so you can ask for, say, every fine-wire sproat dry-fly hook in a single step.
Click a hook in the list to add it to the comparison. You can select between two and four hooks at once; the tool is built around small, focused comparisons rather than long lists, because four columns is about as much as the eye can hold side by side. Each selected hook is assigned a color, and that same color follows it everywhere else in the tool — in the table header, in the visual overlay, and in the match matrix — so you can always tell which hook is which at a glance.
To remove a hook, click the small × on its colored chip, or click the hook again in the list. The selection counter (for example, 2 / 4 selected) tells you how many slots are filled and how many remain.
2 The Two Views: Table and Overlay
Once you have at least one hook selected, two tabs appear: Attribute Table and Visual Overlay. They answer different questions. The table is for reading specifications precisely — it lays out every recorded attribute as text and numbers. The overlay is for seeing shape — it draws the hook silhouettes on a shared scale so size and form differences are literal rather than described. Most comparisons benefit from looking at both: confirm the numbers in the table, then confirm the shape in the overlay.
Switching between the tabs never loses your selection, so you can move back and forth freely.
3 Reading the Attribute Table
In the attribute table, every column is one hook and every row is one specification. The colored dot in each column header matches that hook’s color throughout the tool. Rows are grouped: identification and provenance first, then the design attributes (bend, shank, wire, eye, point, and so on), then measured dimensions where they are available.
The “Agree” column
The second column, headed Agree, is one of the most useful and least obvious parts of the table. For each design specification it shows a fraction — for example 4/4 or 2/3 — telling you how many of the selected hooks share the most common value for that row. The pill is color-coded so you can scan it quickly:
- Green — all selected hooks agree on this specification.
- Amber — a majority agree, but not all.
- Grey — the hooks are split, with no majority value.
The Agree column measures pure agreement only. It deliberately ignores the substitute scoring weights described later, so it answers a simple, honest question: on this exact spec, do these hooks match? That makes it a fast way to spot where two otherwise similar hooks quietly diverge — a different point style or a heavier wire that you might miss reading the columns one at a time.
Documented versus measured
Most rows show the documented specification — the value recorded for that model from catalogs and references. Where a physical example has been measured with calipers, those measured dimensions appear in their own rows below a divider. A measured value reflects the specific example on the bench, which can differ slightly from the catalog nominal. If a hook has no data for a given row, that cell shows a dash (—) rather than a guess.
4 The Visual Overlay
The visual overlay draws the selected hooks’ silhouettes on top of one another, on a shared scale, each in its assigned color. Because the silhouettes are drawn to the same scale, the differences you see are real proportions, not impressions — a wider gap looks wider, a longer shank reaches further, a deeper bend drops lower. This is the quickest way to confirm whether two hooks that look alike on paper are actually the same shape.
The overlay toolbar gives you control over the view:
- Scale — sets the physical display scale so you can match the drawing to a real ruler or print at a known size.
- Zoom — magnifies the whole overlay to inspect a detail such as the point or eye, with a reset to return to the default framing.
- Position and rotation — lets you nudge or rotate an individual hook to align a particular feature for closer comparison, with a reset to put everything back.
A hook appears in the overlay only if it has a normalized silhouette tracing on file. Hooks without a tracing are still listed and still appear in the table; they simply cannot be drawn. As the catalog’s tracings are filled in over time, more hooks become available in the overlay.
5 The Match Matrix
When two or more hooks are selected, a collapsible Match Matrix panel appears above the table. Click its header to expand it. The matrix is a grid showing the weighted percentage agreement between every pair of selected hooks — a single number summarizing how alike each pair is across all the scored specifications at once. It is the fastest way to answer “of these four hooks, which two are the closest?”
Reading the grid is straightforward: find a row hook and a column hook, and the cell where they meet is that pair’s match percentage. Higher is more alike. Click any cell to open a breakdown showing exactly which specifications drove that score, field by field — so you can see not just that two hooks are 88% alike, but why.
The ⊘ symbol
A cell marked with ⊘ instead of a percentage means the two hooks have incompatible hook ply — for example, one is a single hook and the other a double. Ply is treated as a hard gate: hooks of different ply cannot stand in for one another no matter how alike everything else is, so the pair scores zero and is flagged rather than given a misleadingly high number.
6 Finding Substitute Hooks
This is the feature most working tyers reach for. On any selected hook — in the table header or its detail — use the find similar control (marked with a ≈ symbol). It opens a panel that ranks the rest of the catalog by how well each hook could substitute for the one you chose, best match first. Each result carries a match percentage and a quality label (excellent, very good, good, moderate, poor) so you can judge at a glance how close the field gets.
How matches are scored
The score is a weighted blend of how closely two hooks agree across many specifications. By default the design attributes that most define a hook’s character carry the most weight, and cosmetic attributes carry the least. The default emphasis runs roughly in this order:
Two refinements make the scoring more realistic than a simple checklist. First, near-matches earn partial credit: two adjacent wire gauges, or two similar bend families, score as close rather than as a flat miss. Second, hook ply is a hard gate — a ply mismatch removes a candidate from contention entirely, just as in the match matrix. Most other specifications are graded on a sliding scale, so a hook that is close but not identical still ranks well, which is exactly what you want when hunting a practical substitute.
7 Adjusting the Scoring (the ⚙ Settings)
The match percentages are not handed down from on high — you control them. The gear icon (⚙) at the top of the tool opens the scoring settings, with two tabs:
- Weights — sets how much each specification matters, on a scale from 0 to 50. Raise the weight of the things you care about and lower the rest.
- Partial Credit — sets how generously near-matches are rewarded, from 0 (only exact matches count) to 1 (near-matches count almost as much as exact ones).
There is no single correct weighting, because different users are asking different questions. A tyer matching a pattern cares most about gap, wire, and shank length — the dimensions that decide whether the fly sits right and the hook holds. A collector tracing a model’s lineage cares most about bend family and construction. Set the weights to match your purpose; the results re-rank immediately as you adjust.
Your settings are remembered in your browser between visits. Export JSON copies your configuration so you can save or share it, and Reset restores the defaults if you want to start over.
8 Sharing, Printing, and Resetting
Your current comparison is captured in the page’s web address. Copy the URL from your browser’s address bar and anyone who opens it sees the exact same hooks already selected — useful for sharing a comparison in a forum post, an email, or your own notes.
The Export / Print button opens a clean, print-friendly version of the comparison. In the print dialog, choose “Save as PDF” to keep a file, or send it straight to a printer for a bench reference.
The Reset button clears all selections, filters, and overlay adjustments and returns the tool to a clean starting point. It does not change your saved scoring settings.
9 Quick Reference
| Control | What it does |
|---|---|
| Search box & filters | Narrow the catalog to the hooks you want to compare. |
| Click a hook | Add it to the comparison (up to four). |
| Colored chip × | Remove that hook from the comparison. |
| Attribute Table tab | Read every specification side by side. |
| Visual Overlay tab | See the silhouettes superimposed to scale. |
| Agree column | How many hooks share each value — green all, amber majority, grey split. |
| Match Matrix | Pairwise % agreement; click a cell for the breakdown. |
| ⊘ in the matrix | Incompatible hook ply — cannot substitute. |
| ≈ find similar | Rank the catalog by substitute quality for one hook. |
| ⚙ settings | Adjust scoring weights and near-match credit. |
| Export / Print | Open a print-friendly sheet; “Save as PDF” to keep a file. |
| Reset | Clear selections, filters, and overlay (keeps scoring settings). |
| ? Help | Open the condensed in-tool version of this guide. |
