Fly Atlas / Beginner / Thunder and Lightning
Thunder and Lightning
Beginner, 4 of ten. J. H. Hale 1892. Challenge 4/10 · Stage 5 · Earliest located 1895
Full Dress / strip wing Complexity 3 / 5 Stage 5 — Tails, Butts & Simple Strip Wings Rank 11 of 50 · 2 of 4 core books
What are you tying this to?
Level 4 — Museum / Research Reconstruction. A substitute is accepted only where the historical material is legally restricted or genuinely hard to obtain. Everything else asks for the real thing.
No material list on record
No dressing has been transcribed for this fly, so this archive does not hold what it is made of. The material table is absent, not empty — an empty one would imply we looked and found nothing.
Everything else on this page derives from the curriculum rather than from a recipe: where the fly sits, what it teaches and what to practise.
Tails, Butts & Simple Strip Wings
Tail selection/mounting, butt control, matched strip selection, paired wing mounting and clean roof placement.
Stage gate
7/8 tails mount centered; 8/10 strip pairs match before mounting; 7/8 mounted strip wings remain centered with matched tips; roof does not hide the wing.
Advance when
Advance when paired wings can be mounted with 2–3 securing wraps without leaning or exploding head size.
- Tier
- Beginner / 4 of 10
- Teaching challenge
- 4/10
- Next
- Fiery Brown
Only what can ruin this fly
No dressing is transcribed for this fly, so these are chosen from what the curriculum says it teaches rather than from the parts it is built from.
Off the hook
Cut and pair 10 narrow Bronze Mallard roof slips; place each over a printed wing silhouette.
On the hook
Mount 8 roofs over a simple Turkey practice wing.
PX-011 Golden-Pheasant crest selection for tails / PX-012 Tail mounting / PX-016 Ostrich-herl butt control / PX-038 Selecting matched strip-wing slips / PX-039 Mounting paired strip wings — worth doing, but they are not what this fly will punish you for.
Why this fly, at this point
- What it teaches
- Tag; black body; gold rib; orange hackle; throat; Mallard wing; topping
- Why it is here
- A visually unmistakable classic with a relatively direct construction sequence. Excellent for learning how strong color contrast exposes proportion errors.
- What to focus on
- Integrating body, hackle, throat and a simple Mallard wing
- Material challenges
- Blue Jay; Mallard; Jungle Cock; Macaw
The build, with the number to hit
Practical bench targets, not claimed Victorian universal rules. No historical tying sequence exists for any pattern in this archive. See the research-state card.
- B
- dressed body length
- G
- hook gape
- W
- main-wing length
- T
- tail length
- S
- usable shank
- Count
- a count, not a ratio
-
Tag 0.1 × B 0.08 – 0.12
Keep narrow enough that tail, butt and body do not get pushed forward.
Watch for: Tag too long; tag begins too far down bend; body shortened unintentionally. -
Tail Length 1.5 × G 1.25 – 1.6
Measure from the tail tie-in to crest tip, not along the curve of the crest.
Watch for: Tail dominates fly; topping cannot visually meet tail; wing must be stretched to compensate. -
Tail Height / Lift 0.75 × G 0.5 – 1
Choose crest curvature before tying; height is as important as raw length.
Watch for: Flat tail; excessively vertical tail; crest tip falls below wing line. -
Tail Veiling 0.5 × T 0.45 – 0.6
Veiling should support and decorate the tail rather than replace its outline.
Watch for: Veiling hides crest; veiling looks like a second tail; asymmetry. -
Butt 0.04 × B 0.03 – 0.05
Linear percentage is only a planning equivalent; actual width depends on herl/wool diameter.
Watch for: Butt too broad; butt crowds first body section; uneven diameter. -
Dressed Body 0.73 × S 0.68 – 0.78
Reserve front shank for throat, wing tie-in and a compact head.
Watch for: Body runs into eye; wing tie-in forced forward; oversized head. -
Body Hackle Fiber Length 0.82 × G 0.7 – 0.95
Size to preserve body visibility; body hackle should not visually become the throat.
Watch for: Hackle blankets rib/body; fly looks woolly; hackle reaches far below hook. -
Throat Depth / Fiber Length 0.9 × G 0.75 – 1.05
Judge throat against body hackle, not in isolation.
Watch for: Throat too short; throat swallows hook point; body hackle and throat indistinguishable. -
Underwing Length 1.15 × B 1.05 – 1.25
Size the underwing before building the main wing.
Watch for: Underwing protrudes beyond main wing; stepped wing tip; insufficient support. -
Main Wing Length 1.3 × B 1.2 – 1.4
Aim wing tip into the tail/topping framework.
Watch for: Wing ends short of framework; overlong wing drags fly rearward; misaligned tips. -
Main Wing Height 1 × G 0.85 – 1.2
Measure visible vertical mass above the shank.
Watch for: Anemic wing; blocky oversized wing; roof/topping forced too high. -
Roof Length 0.9 × W 0.8 – 1
Roof should cap the wing without becoming a second full-length wing.
Watch for: Roof too short; extends past tail; Mallard overwhelms married wing. -
Roof Height / Coverage 0.625 × G 0.5 – 0.75
Interpret as visible roof profile/coverage rather than literal slip width in every pattern.
Watch for: Roof too narrow; bulky tent; head becomes wide. -
Sides Length 0.65 × W 0.5 – 0.75
Original whole-feather or pattern-specific instructions override this range.
Watch for: Sides become main wing; too short to read; paired lengths mismatch. -
Shoulder Length 0.67 × W 0.6 – 0.75
Shoulders reinforce the front/middle without hiding the wing tip.
Watch for: Shoulder reaches wing tip; stops too close to head; pair mismatch. -
Cheek Length 0.33 × W 0.25 – 0.4
Jungle Cock eye position affects apparent length.
Watch for: Cheeks dominate side; disappear; eye centers unequal. -
Horn Length 1 × W 0.9 – 1.1
Horns should follow the wing/topping line.
Watch for: Horns stop mid-wing; extend beyond topping; cross each other. -
Topping Length 1.02 × W 0.95 – 1.1
Select topping and tail together; they form the fly's outer frame.
Watch for: Topping falls short; extends far past tail; wrong curvature. -
Topping Height 1 × G 0.85 – 1.15
Measure maximum crown above the wing/shank.
Watch for: Topping sits on wing; towers over fly; peak too far forward. -
Head Length 0.05 × B 0.035 – 0.07
Reserve space before tying body; economy of wraps matters more than chasing a number.
Watch for: Large cone head; head far behind eye; material butts exposed. -
Rib Turns 5 turns 4 – 6
Count spaces as well as turns.
Watch for: Crowded rib; only three huge spaces; compound ribs merge visually.
Gallery — 0 member flies
Disclosure is encouraged and pre-filled, but not required — so some tiles carry a level and their substitutions, and some carry neither.
Sign in to share a fly you have tied. Nothing reaches this page without a moderator looking at it first.
One thread per named fly
Ask about a dressing, or say what worked at the vise. Comments are moderated the way every other comment on this site is.
Cite this page
Garren Wood. “Thunder and Lightning.” Retrieved 2026-11-22, from https://garrenwood.com/wp/fly-atlas/pattern/thunder-and-lightning/
