Garren WoodFishing Hook Reference
Save this hook to your account to build a list you can come back to.
H. Milward & Sons Carlisle, model 2814.5, a salmon and sea-trout hook with deep Carlisle bend, blind-marked eye, standard wire, and blued finish, manufactured in England circa 1940–1965. The blind-marked shank was a deliberate choice for British salmon work, allowing direct gut-snell attachment without a terminal loop that could weaken the line or create snag points. Standard wire weight and the rounded bend geometry were engineered for hand-strike setting and baitfish presentations typical of the era. The hook represents the Redditch tradition of purpose-built salmon tackle: a technically specific tool rather than a generalist pattern, now less common in size 1 and valued among collectors of mid-century British fly-tying tackle.
3 cataloged imagesSelect any record to load it above.
3 images shown
Blind Eye | Carlisle | Spear Point | Blued
The blind-marked eye was a deliberate engineering choice for salmon and sea-trout work. Rather than forming a terminal loop that could snag or weaken the shank, the maker marked a ridge or thickening on the shank itself, creating a surface to which the tyer could whip a gut snell. This kept the hook profile clean and minimized catch points on the line.
The Carlisle’s rounded bend provides a generous bite angle suitable for large baitfish and enables deep hook-setting force when hand-striked (the predominant technique in British salmon fishing of the era). Standard wire weight balances durability against the need for hand-casting with fly rod and multiplier reel.
Blued finish was a cost-effective and reliable protective coating applied through oxidation. The cool blue-grey tone is visually distinctive and resists rust better than uncoated steel in salt-spray and brackish-water environments where sea-trout hooks are deployed.
Known manufactured size range: 1-14 I
Physical measurement with calipers
This pattern was made in sizes 1-14 (I). We have measurement for size 1. Know the others? Submit calipered measurements and we'll review and add them. Thank you!
H. Milward & Sons was a Redditch, England–based fishhook manufacturer founded in the 19th century and prominent through the mid-20th century. Milward operated as one of the major craft-era producers alongside Allcock, Partridge, and other Redditch houses. The company was known for a wide range of bend patterns, reliable bluing and bronzing processes, and steady export trade to Britain’s angling market.
Milward hooks were widely distributed through tackle dealers and mail-order catalogs. The “Quality” designation system (e.g., Quality 2814.5) reflected different commercial grades, wire gauges, and finish specifications within the Milward range—allowing retailers to offer cost variants of the same pattern.
H. Milward & Sons ceased independent operation in the mid-to-late 20th century as industrial consolidation and overseas competition reshaped the British fishing-tackle industry. Surviving Milward hooks remain common in original packaging and are actively collected by specialists in Redditch craft production.
The Carlisle pattern is a long-standing British salmon-hook design characterized by a deep rounded bend and blind eye — designed for direct snelling to gut leaders, the standard leader material for salmon fishing through the 1960s. The blind-marked shank eliminated the risk of a looped eye snagging on rod guides or leader coils.
Carlisle hooks were produced by multiple Redditch makers (Partridge, Allcock, Milward) and represented a standard commercial offering from the early 20th century onward. Milward’s Quality 2814.5 is one documented variant within this broader pattern family. The Carlisle lost commercial prominence after 1970 as modern eyed salmon hooks (with brazed or looped terminal eyes) displaced blind-marked patterns, and nylon monofilament simplified leader attachment.
The pattern survives in fly-dressing tradition primarily through specialist collectors and historical reenactors interested in period-authentic Scottish and Northern English salmon techniques.
No barcode visible on packaging — strong indicator of pre-1974 manufacture V. Card stock is cream-colored kraft, typical of 1940s-1960s English hook packaging. Print method appears to be letterpress or early offset, consistent with 1940s-1950s. Label design and typography match Milward's documented catalogs from the mid-20th century. Blued finish with clean oxide layer suggests mid-century production rather than pre-1930 hooks. Quality marking "2814.5" is characteristic of Milward's wartime and post-war commercial grades. Based on cumulative evidence, the production window is estimated c. 1940-1965.
The Carlisle pattern descends from 19th-century British salmon-hook tradition. Related patterns include the Sneck (similar rounded bend but usually with a different eye construction), the sproat-derived sea-trout patterns, and the O’Shaughnessy (a competing deep-bend design with more pronounced angle). The Carlisle represents the lighter end of British salmon hooks — directly competing with Limerick and other standard bends in a crowded market.
Successors to the Carlisle include modern eyed salmon hooks (Partridge Willie Gunn, Mustad Salmon, etc.), which displaced blind-marked patterns after 1965. The Carlisle survives in niche practice among anglers committed to period methods and traditional aesthetic.
| Silhouette | Hook Model | Match | Analysis | Compare |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Chestertown No. 1 — Chestertown | 80% | Compare | ||
| Aberdeen — Aberdeen | 79% | Compare | ||
|
3781 No. 7/0 — Harrison's Genuine Kendal Round Bent Hook — Quality 3781 | 78% | Compare | |
|
2310 R No. 16 — Milward 2310 R | 77% | Compare | |
| Not documented No. 2/0 — Kirby Tapered | 75% | Compare |
| Silhouette | Hook Model | Match | Compare |
|---|---|---|---|
|
679 No. 12 — Allcock 679 | 98% | Compare |
|
37360 No. 3/0 — Aberdeen Hook | 96% | Compare |
|
2996 No. 1 — Spring Steel Carlisle Hooks | 95% | Compare |
|
993DH No. true — Custom's Hump Long Shank | 95% | Compare |
|
10371 No. 5 — H. Milward & Sons' 10371 | 94% | Compare |
Salmon and sea-trout fishing with natural bait (sand eels, sprats, small live fish) or traditional dressed flies. The blind-marked eye and standard wire accommodate direct snelling with gut leader material, the standard method for British coastal salmon fishing through the 1960s. Size 1 sits between typical small-fly salmon sizes (No. 4-6 dressed) and heavy-wire bait hooks, suggesting mixed use for both dressed flies on small spates and bait work on larger water.
Named patterns specifically associated with this hook. Leave blank if none formally documented. Do not speculate — only include patterns with a confirmed association.
Rated 3.5/10 — widely available in original packaging but collector demand is limited and size-dependent. Size 1 is less common than larger sizes. Blind-marked eye construction appeals to specialists in British salmon tradition and Redditch craft production, but general fly-tying interest is low given the shift to modern eyed patterns.
Positive factors: Original cream card with printed label remains intact; no barcode indicates pre-1974 manufacture, a collecting marker for older Redditch gear; blued finish in uniform condition; complete spade-end construction documents a manufacturing method no longer common; historical significance in British salmon tradition.
Limiting factors: Blind-marked eye construction limits utility for modern anglers (no way to tie on without snelling); Milward Carlisle hooks remain reasonably available in original packaging on secondary markets; collector demand is narrow — specialists in Redditch gear and period-method salmon anglers only; larger sizes (2/0, 3/0) are much more common than size 1, which sees moderate searching to locate.
Desirability drivers: Smaller sizes (1, 2, 4) command modest premiums over larger sizes; sealed or near-sealed card adds 20-30% to value; Redditch maker name and craft-era production date; any size with original tissue or wrapping intact.
Condition factors: Card must be complete and legible to support a meaningful premium; hooks should show no corrosion or pitting (blued finish is susceptible to surface oxidation with age); missing hooks or loose packaging reduce value by 30-50%.
Cream kraft card approximately 3.5" × 1.75" (89mm × 44mm) with printed label band. Label is dark brown/tan cardstock with black letterpress print. Text reads "SPEAR POINTED / Carlisle / Marked / No. / Quality - - 2814.5 / [two fly illustrations]". No barcode or modern printing marks. Card appears folded or scored along the center to hold hooks. Worn edges and light toning consistent with 1950s-1960s storage and handling. Original label band glued or pasted to cream substrate.
Low ($4): Good condition — opened card, most or all hooks present, card shows wear and toningnHigh ($12): Excellent condition — sealed or near-sealed card, complete hook count, minimal defects, legible labelnPremium factors: Size 1 (less common than larger sizes); Redditch craft-era manufacture; intact original packaging; clean blued finish with no corrosionnPlatforms: eBay UK, vintage tackle dealers, specialist fly-tying forumsnConfidence: E estimated — limited comparable sales data; based on typical Redditch hook card pricing and size premium for smaller Carlisle sizes
eBay UK (vintage fishing tackle section); specialist British tackle dealers (Orvis Heritage, UK vintage fly-fishing suppliers); tackle fairs in the Midlands and North of England; online forums dedicated to classic fly-fishing techniques.
The printed label on the cream card shows no evidence of handwritten annotations or collector marks. All text is letterpress or early offset print. The label includes: ‘SPEAR POINTED’ (size designation and point style), ‘Carlisle’ (pattern name), ‘Marked’ (eye construction), ‘No.’ (size number follows), ‘Quality – – 2814.5’ (commercial grade and model code), and two small fly illustrations in black ink.
The model code ‘2814.5’ is the primary identifier for this hook within Milward’s product range. The decimal indicates a variant or sub-grade within the numbering hierarchy. No handwritten price, date, or retailer mark is visible on the specimen examined.
The label marking ‘No. 1’ indicates this is a Milward Size 1 hook, measured on the British standard scale where smaller numerical sizes represent hooks used for smaller flies and more delicate work. Size 1 falls between the salmon-fly sizes (typically 2-10) and the larger sizes (1/0, 2/0, etc. used for sea fishing and pike).
Size 1 Carlisle hooks are less commonly encountered than larger sizes (2/0, 3/0) in the original packaging market. This size distribution reflects the historical pattern of salmon fishing: most commercial and amateur effort focused on standard sizes, with size 1 representing a specialized intermediate offering for small streams or summer spates. Collectors of Redditch hooks often prize smaller sizes precisely because they are more difficult to locate in original condition.
| P | Photographically verified — Directly observable in the photograph(s) on this page. |
| V | Verified by documentation — Confirmed by manufacturer catalog, spec sheet, or published reference. |
| I | Inferred — A logical deduction from observable or documented evidence, not directly stated. |
| E | Estimated — An approximation based on visual comparison, proportional analysis, or limited data. |
| S | Speculative — A reasoned hypothesis that cannot be confirmed from available evidence. |
Claims with no notation are confirmed by multiple independent sources. All photographs on garrenwood.com are taken on a measurement grid where each square equals 1/10 inch (0.1″ / 2.54 mm).
Your cart is empty.